To the Editor:

In simple terms, let us engage in discussions; let us motivate our residents not only to express their opinions but also to trust that their voices will lead to action, rather than merely participating in a one-sided board hearing format where their numerous questions remain unanswered.

Let us make a decision right now, beginning with your vote, regarding the actions of today rather than postponing them for yet another decade.

I would like to express, as I campaign for office to represent the people, that in light of an allegation made by a town board member (Adam Greenberg) who accused me of  “... lying to voters,” [“Stop lying to voters, stop trying to break what we have built,” The Altamont Enterprise, Oct. 17, 2025]

However, nah — I will refrain from engaging in that jargon and simply state this: Having visited over 1,500 homes and having nearly as many discussions conducted with my colleague, Chris Mielke, and me, Craig A. Shufelt, it is the actions stemming from these conversations that will be of utmost importance and will be significantly taken into account locally during this upcoming election.

As we both strive to achieve the difficult objective of meeting every member of our community in person, several key town-wide issues raised by our neighbors distinctly emerge:

— One, BESS is a significant concern that appears to be a prevalent topic of discussion throughout the town, with many expressing that “it’s simply not what we desire near the comfortable backyards of our cherished homes.”

Additionally, numerous individuals have inquired about BESS, as it appears to conflict with the recently enacted “open spaces” plan adopted by the town. It is these very conflicting messages that have raised concerns among our residents, thereby reinforcing the questions: Why here? Why now? posed by many of our neighbors in the community.

Another board member (Dan Leinung) stated to The Enterprise recently, “... this was the largest attendance I have seen at a town meeting.” [“We believe New Scotland BESS law is the strictest in the state,” The Altamont Enterprise, Oct. 17, 2025]

He further wrote, “It was great to see the public so engaged on this important project in the town.” With such a widespread turnout, residents expressed their distinct opposition to such projects in our town vocally and often with repeated applause throughout the standing-room-only board room. That should be the clarity the town and planning board acknowledges and acts collectively upon.

I also find it intriguing that a decade ago, there was a unanimous board decision against the use of digitally powered LED commercial signage due to ambient light pollution in front of any business, yet the same town board is now seeking to approve multiple 5 MW industrial-sized battery-storage systems in various locations. Let us apply some common sense.

The passage of the local law to accommodate certain interests does not imply that this law will be beneficial for all residents! It seems to me to suit some but not all. It also does not seem to limit the number of BESS units per property throughout town or the maximum power credentials, only the minimum.

Once more, I ask: Why here? Why now?

— Two, significant issues continue to raise concerns, notably the Hilton barn project, which has now exceeded 10 years in duration, is out of scope, and over budget, accompanied by two related lawsuits.

Furthermore, there is still no functioning restroom, let alone a completed solution that would benefit the community. Is the original barn that was intended to be preserved truly the historic structure it once represented?

Have we overspent in our efforts to maintain it, thereby neglecting opportunities to enhance our future in other areas of the town? I pose these questions and also suggest, “In the next decade, let us strive for improvement! Please let’s do better!”

— Finally, there are several remaining issues that warrant attention, such as the repercussions with CSX and the railroads; the availability of town water; the lack of internet access in all households; the necessity for crosswalks and additional speed zones; the need for sidewalks to enhance safety between schools; and improvements in Feura Bush, which would continue to promote a “walkable cozy Main Street vibe.”

Our veterans continue to be overlooked, and our seniors are not receiving the attention they deserve for their concerns either. These are all matters that our board should actively address rather than merely feigning interest.

If elected as your next board member, I pledge that these matters will indeed be addressed and advanced.

I openly express my emotions, and residents can rely on my honor, character, pride, and ethics on my behalf — it’s not personal, it’s business; err wait, for me, yes, it’s very personal — and I am not lyin’.

Craig A. Shufelt

New Scotland

Editor’s note: Craig A. Shufelt is running for New Scotland Town board on the Republican and conservative lines.