Crossgates appraisal drops nearly 65% from pre-pandemic valuation

— Enterprise file photo

An appraisal performed in March valued Crossgates Mall at $167 million, which is down nearly 65 percent from a pre-pandemic valuation of $470 million.

GUILDERLAND — After being appraised for $470 million just a few short years ago, Crossgates Mall now has a valuation of $167 million. 
In July 2020, amid the early months of the pandemic, Crossgates’ appraised value was lowered from $470 million to $281 million. This March, that number was lowered once again, this time to $167 million.

The devaluation news was included as part of a report in the Commercial Real Estate Direct newsletter about the mall’s loan debt being sold at auction for a near 30-percent discount. 

Real-estate data firm Trepp reported on Aug. 18 that Crossgates’ once-$242 million in loans were sold for nearly $174 million, which, after subtracting $29.6 million in liquidation expenses, left $144 million in net proceeds — an approximately $98 million loss for bondholders. 

“The loss comes a little out of the blue,” Trepp wrote. “The loan was originally slated to mature in May 2022, but a modification pushed the maturity to this month. The loan was current following the modification and ahead of the resolution.”

“Newmark appraised the property last March at a value of $167 million,” Commercial Real Estate Direct reported on Aug. 25. “Other appraisals and brokers’ opinions of value had pegged the property’s value between $146.7 million and $157.2 million, according to servicer notes compiled by Trepp Inc.”

An appraisal is performed to determine the market value of a property at a certain date, under a certain set of conditions. It is an opinion. Loan lenders often use appraisals to determine the value of a property.

 Commercial Real Estate Direct said the loan had an original balance of $300 million, which “allowed Pyramid to refinance what then was a $181.1 million mortgage and take $110.3 million of cash out of the property. ”

Pyramid Management Group, in response to a request from The Enterprise, said in a statement, “We do not have any comment at this time.”

More Guilderland News

  • The Sept. 22 lawsuit was filed by Mattress Express employee Kimberly Blasiak against Pyramid Management Group, a half-dozen of its local LLCs, and Urban Air Adventure Park.

  • Guilderland Cemetery, formerly known as the Reformed Church Cemetery, was on the original 1794 lease of 43.75 acres from the proprietor of the manor of Rensselaerwyck, Stephen Van Rensselaer, to ministers, elders, and deacons of Reformed Protestant Dutch Church. The cemetery was turned over to the town of Guilderland in 2002 when the Guilderland Cemetery Association could no longer afford to keep it up.

  • GUILDERLAND — BARE Blends, a women-owned, healthy-foods eatery, which moved across Stuyvesant Pla

The Altamont Enterprise is focused on hyper-local, high-quality journalism. We produce free election guides, curate readers' opinion pieces, and engage with important local issues. Subscriptions open full access to our work and make it possible.