First draft Plans to shape development simmer

NEW SCOTLAND — Long the center of debate over the future of development in town, the land at the intersection of routes 85 and 85A was discussed in some detail as a committee charged with recommending a new zoning code for that area met to go over the first draft of recommendations. In the same week, farmers met at the cooperative extension in a statewide Small Farm Summit to tackle the issues they face.

The hundreds of acres of land at the intersection of routes 85 and 85A, which is zoned for commercial development but has only ever been used for agriculture, became a focal point for the town when Cazenovia-based Sphere Development proposed building a Target-anchored shopping center there; the former Bender melon farm has been owned by a group of investors since 1971. Maura Mottolese, the lawyer representing the group and the daughter of one investor, sits on the committee, as does Katie O’Rourke, who with her husband owns a sizeable piece of land at the intersection that they hope to develop.

The draft that the committee was discussing came out of a public workshop held at the end of last year in which many of the 100 residents who attended expressed a desire to keep the land as it is or to build a quaint, village-like development on it.

The draft suggested that part of the land would be put into an agricultural conservation area. Based on the amount of her clients’ land that would be covered by that area, Mottolese said, “I can tell you right now, the owners will not be happy about that.”

Michael Welti, a planner with Behan Planning Associates who was hired to work with the committee, largely developed the draft. He declined to release the draft to The Enterprise this week since it is still in rough form.

Mottolese also contested the classification of some of the soil on her clients’ land as “soils of statewide importance” and “prime soils.”

According to the United States Department of Agriculture, 34 percent of the 200-acre Bender farm is prime farmland and 12 percent is farmland of statewide significance.

Mottolese pointed out that, during the public forum, Timothy Stanton, a farmer who lost his bid for town board in the last two elections with a platform supportive of development, had said that much of the land on the former Bender farm was not conducive to farming.

Mottolese disputed the viability of community supported agriculture, organic farming, or niche farming for the area.

“I don’t think those are pie-in-the-sky ideas. They’re possibilities,” Welti responded, adding that more than just commercial development was possible for the area. A significant portion of the community expects to see agricultural or open space, Welti said.

“And when they buy the land, they can do that,” Mottolese responded.

Her clients bought the property for about $525,000 and, when Sphere was planning to buy it in 2008, they were asking $4 million.

According to the most recent census of agriculture, performed by the United States Department of Agriculture in 2007, between 29 and 34 percent of farmers in Albany County were beginning farmers, meaning that they had begun within the last 10 years.

Nearly 50 people, including farmers and students of agriculture, gathered at the Cornell Cooperative Extension in Voorheesville to join a statewide discussion of the issues facing small farms.

“There could be a renaissance” of farming in New York, said Marybeth Vargha, who runs a community supported agriculture, or CSA, farm nearby.


More New Scotland News

  • Due to increases in expected sales-tax revenue in 2021-22 and a new very favorable waste-services contract, the village of Voorheesville will not have to tap its rainy-day fund for much money to close its budget gap for next year. 

  • Azam Khan and Marielle McKasty-Stagg are seeking a position as library trustee in Voorh

  • At its April 13 meeting, the Voorheesville Planning Commission heard not one but two presentations from area entrepreneurs looking to open restaurants in the village — one a craft brewery and restaurant; the other, an eatery that has yet to be determined. 

The Altamont Enterprise is focused on hyper-local, high-quality journalism. We produce free election guides, curate readers' opinion pieces, and engage with important local issues. Subscriptions open full access to our work and make it possible.