Berne sewer district nearly $35K short because of tax-bill error

Enterprise file photo — Marcello Iaia

The treatment facility for Berne’s sewer district opened in 2014.

BERNE — Residents of Berne’s sewer district were mistakenly undercharged for sewer services this year, which left the district fund nearly $34,563 short. As a result, the town is figuring out how it will recoup those funds from the district’s residents.

Lyons told The Enterprise that the sewer district comprises 99 Equivalent Dwelling Units, or EDUs, the unit of measure by which residents are charged for sewer usage. 

“Some EDUs in Berne serve two single-family homes,” he said in an email, “some serve municipal buildings, some are commercial services, and a few are actually ½ EDUs based on size and flow.”

Lyons said that the majority of EDUs owe “$319 and change. A few [owe] a couple thousand and a few [owe] less than $150.”

In the meeting, Lyons explained that the shortage resulted from a clerical error made in the town assessor’s office when the tax bills were being constructed.

“It is basically a clerical error where the wrong line in the spreadsheet was used ...,” Lyons said. “Again, they used the operation and maintenance per EDU as opposed to the levy. Obviously the levy is the full tax. It’s the maintenance plus the service.” 

The assessor’s office — which is made up of Chairman Brian Crawford and assessors Christine Valachovic and Melanie Bunzey — confirmed for The Enterprise that “the wrong column of data was entered in preparation for the January 2021 tax bill.”

While it’s known how much is owed and by whom, the procedure of getting the money is less straightforward. Lyons said during the meeting that the town can either petition the county legislature for permission to adjust the tax warrant, which he said would be a “long and lengthy process,” or, the loss could be absorbed this year and taxpayers would pay an added tax in January 2022 for their owed amount. 

Like other special tax districts, Berne’s sewer district is self-sufficient, funded entirely by the taxpayers who reside there. 

No decision was made at the March 10 meeting, as Lyons said he was waiting for more detailed information on the petitioning process, and board members seemed eager to contact affected residents and find out what their preferences would be.

Lyons said that letters would go out “almost immediately” to district residents to alert them to the shortage and the fact that they’ll need to cover their share, whether that be sooner or later.

More Hilltowns News

  • Republican Assemblyman Chris Tague’s re-election grants him another two years in an office he’s held since 2018. A dairy farmer with experience in local government and the private sector, Tague has promised to continue promoting rural causes in the state legislature.

  • Berne Supervisor Dennis Palow made the rare decision to speak with The Enterprise this week, offering his side of two allegations that have defined the town for at least the past few months: that he has allowed the town to drift into financial ruin, and that he meanwhile had created such a hostile work environment that three of his fellow Republican-backed town board members resigned.

  • Executive Director for the New York State Association of Towns Chris Koetzle laid out for The Enterprise how Berne may be able to go about enacting its current draft budget for 2025 without a board to authorize it, or vote to override the 2 percent tax cap. However, he warned that the situation was unprecedented and that it’s up to the comptroller’s office to determine how to proceed. 

The Altamont Enterprise is focused on hyper-local, high-quality journalism. We produce free election guides, curate readers' opinion pieces, and engage with important local issues. Subscriptions open full access to our work and make it possible.